Welcome back to the BAIG newsletter!

When assessing investments one can make, attention typically centers on traditional assets like stocks and bonds. However, an increasingly prominent alternative lies in tangible collectibles. Over recent decades, high-end watches, fine art, collector automobiles, and trading cards have transitioned from personal hobbies into recognized alternative assets that have the capability of exponential returns. Rather than relying on corporate earnings, or economic factors, these markets are dictated by scarcity, historical and cultural significance, and physical condition. Yet beneath record-setting auction sales, tangible collectibles remain highly speculative, and vulnerable to shifting consumer tastes and substantial holding costs. We hope you enjoy reading our 2nd edition this semester of the BAIG Monthly Newsletter!

❝

You’re reading BAIG’s Monthly Newsletter — A big thank you to our BAIG members! We wanted to thank you for reading, and invite you to subscribe to receive future editions and updates on the latest deals, market trends, and deep dives into the world of alternative investments.

— The Bentley Alternative Investment Group

Hard Assets

Part One: Cars

Unlike traditional investments, cars are typically depreciating assets. They lose value as they age, require regular maintenance, and accumulate mileage. However, certain vehicles can deviate from this pattern and become sought-after collectibles. Factors such as historical significance, limited production, originality, and unique engineering can create scarcity in the market and increase collector demand. In some cases, this has pushed values well beyond a car’s original price, turning these vehicles into alternative assets that can be compared with other collectibles such as art, watches, and wine, which we will discuss later. While the most extreme examples are seen in rare supercars, more attainable enthusiast cars have also experienced value increases as clean, original examples become more difficult to find.

One of the most extreme examples of collectible car value is the 1955 Mercedes-Benz 300 SLR Uhlenhaut Coupé. Only two examples were ever produced, and in 2022, Mercedes-Benz sold one at auction for €135 million (~$143 million at the time), making it the most valuable car ever sold at auction. The car’s rarity, racing heritage, and unique engineering all contributed to this extraordinary figure.

The Mercedes-Benz 300 SLR Uhlenhaut Coupé, the most valuable car in the world.

A more modern example is the McLaren F1, which has become one of the most sought-after collector cars of the modern era. McLaren produced 106 F1s between 1992 and 1998, with only 64 built as standard road cars. The F1 combined a naturally aspirated BMW V12, six-speed manual transmission, central driving position, and carbon-fiber construction with an extremely limited production run. In 2021, a 1995 McLaren F1 sold for $20.47 million at auction, a record price for the model at the time. More recently, in 2025, a 1994 F1 sold for $25.32 million, setting a new record. While these were different individual cars, both sales demonstrate how scarcity, engineering significance, and sustained collector demand can drive high valuations in the collector-car market.

While the Mercedes-Benz 300 SLR Uhlenhaut Coupé and the McLaren F1 have both skyrocketed in value, these cars were costly to begin with, and thus were never realistic purchases for the average buyer. The McLaren F1, for example, cost £540,000 new, which was roughly $828,000 at the time. However, collectible value has also been found in far more attainable cars. The 1999 Honda Civic Si had a base price of just $17,860 when new. Today, Hagerty values a 2000 Civic Si in good condition at ~$17,100, while an excellent example is valued at $37,400 and a concours-quality example at $50,600. Hagerty even recorded a sale of $66,000 in January of 2025. These values show how an affordable enthusiast car can become collectible over time as original, clean examples become harder to find.

2000 Honda Civic Si – this example sold for $52,500 in 2020

Looking ahead, performance cars that have been recently discontinued may point towards the next generation of collectibles. The Audi R8 is one potential example. Audi produced 45,949 R8s between 2007 and 2024, with the final car leaving production in March 2024. Variants of the R8, for example the R8 V10 GT RWD, were produced in smaller numbers, with only 333 examples being made worldwide. This limited-edition model featured a 5.2-liter, naturally aspirated V10, and was one of the final versions of the R8 before Audi stopped its production. Older R8s may also have long-term collector potential, especially ones optioned with manual transmissions.

2023 Audi R8 V10 GT RWD – Base MSRP: $249,900

As the automotive industry continues to evolve, qualities like a naturally aspirated engine, manual transmission, and unique engineering may be increasingly important to collectors. Of course, collectible cars are not guaranteed investment vessels. Mileage, condition, originality, maintenance history, and collector demand are all factors in valuing individual vehicles. Still, examples ranging from the Mercedes-Benz 300 SLR Uhlenhaut Coupé to the Honda Civic Si serve as proof that cars across the automotive market can become valuable collectibles.

Part Two: Trading Cards

When we think of investments, a lot of investors immediately think of stocks and bonds, often forgetting a more niche investment: trading cards. Collecting trading cards has been a hobby for fans of media and sports for decades, but it’s increasing popularity has begun to attract investors who believe certain cards can skyrocket in value, over time or immediately. Fueled by limitations on printing runs, strong cultural relevance, and high-profile auction sales, trading cards have been considered an investment opportunity, compared to assets such as art, vintage, watches and alternative investments.

One of the major drivers for why the card industry has shifted so drastically has been the services of third-party grading services, one of the most prominent being PSA. Card grading has not only verified the condition of the card but created a clear price baseline for the cards worth. Rather than guessing values, buyers can analyze historical sales data (For EX: How Lebron cards have sold in the past), monitor liquidity, and track supply metrics, sharing similar traits of running a quick comps analysis on a specific company.

One of the most notable and recent trading card sales made was the Cooper Flagg 2025-26 Topps Chrome Update 1/1 NBA Debut Patch Autograph rookie which sold for $8.04 million to Fanatics Collect, which broke records as the most expensive single-player basketball card ever sold, dethroning the $6.2 million Stephen Curry National Treasures Logoman card. But how did a single basketball card sell for more than a sports car or even a mid-tier mansion? The answer comes down to the scarcity, demand, and story of the card itself. As an alternative investment, trading cards share similarities with art and collectibles, where value is driven by its rarity, cultural significance, and buyer demand rather than the company’s earnings or cash flow. Nonetheless, these assets are highly speculative, and their prices can fluctuate on player performance, market trends, and sentimental value from collectors.

Subscribe to keep reading

This content is free, but you must be subscribed to Bentley Alternative Investments Group Newsletter to continue reading.

Already a subscriber?Sign in.Not now